Best Schools - Labour’s promise to abolish private schools benefits no one

The argument is, in short, that private schools ought to be abolished because they produce unequal educational outcomes (relative to state schools), which propagate into adulthood and stratify society into classes founded primarily on the private-state divide. However, it is unclear whether the abolition of private schools will actually end this. For example, wealthier parents will still advantage their children through private tutoring, language classes, prestigious internships and cultural visits, as is their right.

At present, around 6.5% of British children attend private schools, rising to 15% of students over the age of 16. The absorption of these students into the already fragile, underfunded and understaffed state school system would be extremely detrimental. The repercussions include an estimated £3.5 billion shortfall to maintain the same level of per-pupil funding, which would either decrease the resources available to all students, or increase the tax burden for the entire country.

Neither route is likely to improve the educational outcomes of state school or private school students. Such a policy could also lead to a worsening of the teacher shortage currently affecting students, as it may lead to fewer graduates entering teaching due to them no longer having the motivation of a large earning potential in the private sector. Although the vast majority of teachers pursue their career with non-financial motivations, financial considerations will always play a part, however small.

The consequences of pursuing such a policy on wider society include the following: the loss of an estimated 300,000 jobs, an associated £4.1 billion in tax revenue, and the human capital that private schools excel at cultivating. One estimate by Oxford Economics predicts that the UK’s GDP would have been £73 billion lower in 2017 had private schools ceased to exist in the 1940s.

As part of this policy, Labour has suggested a ‘redistribution’ of the assets of these private schools. This is a terrible idea. These assets are the results of hundreds of years worth of charitable donations. The forcible seizure of these assets, donated in good faith, is morally corrupt. We cannot dictate where people ought to spend their money.

Furthermore, the income gained from these monetary assets is frequently used to assist poorer families in affording high-quality private schooling. For example, more than 1300 schools are constituents of the Independent Schools Council, and together they contribute over £800 million annually to less wealthy families in the form of fee reductions. At Eton College, approximately 20% of students receive an average fee reduction of 67%, with 90 students attending for free.

This policy does not benefit parents, private schools, and most pressingly, it does not benefit state schools.

Independent Schools of the Year 2019 Awards Results Revealed

The winners of Independent Schools of the Year 2019 have been announced at an awards ceremony held in central London. The awards were hosted by Dr Helen Wright, Chair of the independent panel of 14 judges who selected the winners from more than 250 nominations.

Guests and leading figures from across the sector enjoyed the celebrations of this the second year of the awards campaign, which was hosted by Independent School Parent magazine.